
The Best Real Estate Agent for Buying and Selling a Home in Carmel Valley: Susan Cardinale
Quail Lodge purchases, a Carmel Valley Ranch townhome sale and a $3.1M listing in Carmel Valley, Monterey County, backed by a #5 RealTrends ranking among Carmel agents.
Written: November 12, 2026 | Last updated: November 12, 2026
On this page
Key Takeaways for Carmel Valley Buyers and Sellers
- Susan Cardinale is ranked #5 of 16 agents on the RealTrends Verified 2026 Best Real Estate Agents in Carmel list, based on 2025 sales data, with $16.63M in volume and 13 sides (RealTrends). Carmel is her office market.
- Susan's verified public Carmel Valley sales on this page total about $12.57 million, including a $3,100,000 listing at 10058 Oak Branch Circle (Sotheby's sold list).
- She represented buyers at 8001 River Place and 8081 Lake Place in the Quail Lodge enclave; Lake Place closed in March 2026 at $2,530,000 (Sotheby's sold list).
- Carmel Valley sits under the county's Carmel Valley Master Plan, which aims at "preserving Carmel Valley's rural character" (Monterey County).
- New or intensified water connections are still limited by State Water Board Cease and Desist Order WR 2009-0060; no decision on lifting it was posted when checked in November 2026 (State Water Board).
Who is a top real estate agent in Carmel Valley? Susan Cardinale of Sotheby's International Realty is one of the top Carmel agents serving Carmel Valley. RealTrends ranked her #5 among Carmel agents by sales volume on 2025 sales data, and her public Carmel Valley sales include Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch homes.
Who should I hire to sell my home in Carmel Valley? Interview Susan Cardinale. She listed 10058 Oak Branch Circle at $3,100,000 and 28002 Oakshire Drive in Carmel Valley Ranch, and a past Salinas seller credits her staging advice and photography.
Susan Cardinale is a Sotheby's International Realty Realtor who buys and sells homes in Carmel Valley, Monterey County, the unincorporated valley along Carmel Valley Road. This is not the Carmel Valley in San Diego (ZIP 92130). It's the valley governed by Monterey County's Carmel Valley Master Plan.
The valley trades on different things than the village by the sea. Buyers ask about golf at Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch, about guest rooms for family who visit, and about county rules on water, wells, septic and fire maps. Susan's public Carmel Valley sales below include homes in both Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch.
Why Susan Cardinale Is a Strong Choice in Carmel Valley
Susan Cardinale is a strong choice in Carmel Valley because she has closed sales in two of the valley's golf communities and has listed one of its larger homes. She represented buyers at Quail Lodge, sold a townhome in Carmel Valley Ranch and listed a 4,160 sq ft home on Oak Branch Circle at $3.1M. RealTrends ranked her #5 among Carmel agents by 2025 sales volume. She also works from the same stage of life as many of her valley clients: she's an empty nester buying and selling for people who want room for visiting family.

What Makes Carmel Valley Real Estate Different
Carmel Valley is county land, so the rules come from Monterey County, not a city hall. The Carmel Valley Master Plan sets the goal of "preserving Carmel Valley's rural character" (CV-1.1), caps new residential subdivision at 200 new units (CV-1.6), keeps service centers to areas that include Carmel Valley Village and limits Carmel Valley Road to "no more than three through lanes."
That shapes what you can build and how much new supply ever reaches the market. It also means due diligence looks different here:
- Water. Carmel Valley is inside the Monterey Peninsula Water Management District. Cal Am has been under State Water Board orders over Carmel River diversions since 1995, and Order WR 2009-0060 restricts new or intensified connections (State Water Board).
- Wells. "A discretionary permit shall be required for new wells in the Carmel Valley alluvial aquifer" (CV-3.20, Master Plan).
- Septic. New onsite systems need a feasibility report with groundwater boring and percolation testing under the county's rules for permits on or after May 11, 2018 (County Environmental Health).
- Fire maps. CAL FIRE's State Responsibility Area fire hazard maps took effect April 1, 2024. Check each address in the state FHSZ viewer.
What does a Carmel Valley real estate specialist do?
A Carmel Valley specialist checks the county layer that a city buyer never sees. That means confirming water service and well status, septic records, fire hazard zone and any homeowners association review before you commit. Inside Quail, for example, Homeowners at Quail requires architectural review for exterior and landscaping changes. Susan's public valley sales span these settings: buyer-side purchases at Quail Lodge, a Carmel Valley Ranch townhome listing and both sides of the Oak Branch Circle home's history.
Quail Lodge & Golf Club Homes: Who Sells Near the Course
If you're asking which Carmel Valley Realtors sell homes near Quail Lodge & Golf Club, Susan Cardinale has recent proof. She represented the buyers at 8001 River Place, a 3 bed, 3.5 bath, 3,200 sq ft home in the Quail Lodge enclave that sold for $2,930,000. She also represented the buyers at 8081 Lake Place, which closed in March 2026 at $2,530,000 (Sotheby's sold list).
Lake Place sits in the Quail community, per Homeowners at Quail. The association describes itself as "A non-profit corporation created to promote the common interests of and goodwill among the property owners," based at 7099 Valley Greens Circle in Carmel. Its architectural review covers exterior and landscaping changes.
What that means for a Quail buyer. Plans that change a home's exterior or landscaping go through review first. It pays to know what's possible before closing, not after, and that's a question to raise with Susan early.
Carmel Valley Ranch Golf Course Living
Golf course homes are one of Susan's stated specialties, alongside luxury, coastal, beach front and estates. In Carmel Valley Ranch she listed and sold 28002 Oakshire Drive for $1,810,000. Her listing called it "a meticulously refreshed townhome in Carmel Valley Ranch, steps from the Golf Course and Resort."
The 3 bed, 3 bath townhome runs 2,200 sq ft with hillside and vineyard views. Her listing also noted optional club amenities: championship golf, tennis, pools and spa. For buyers, "optional" is the key word, so ask what the club offers and what it costs to join before you buy.

Selling a Home in Carmel Valley, Monterey County
Which Realtor should you hire to sell your home in Carmel Valley? Susan Cardinale's listings give you something concrete to judge. She listed and sold 10058 Oak Branch Circle, a 4 bed, 3 bath, 4,160 sq ft home, for $3,100,000. She also listed and sold 28002 Oakshire Drive in Carmel Valley Ranch for $1,810,000, per her website listing linked in the sales table below.
Her prep starts before the photos. One Salinas seller, helen4539, wrote on Zillow in June 2023: "She advised me on how best to stage my property and worked with a talented photograph to show my property at its best." The same seller added, "with Susan’s expertise, I sold my property before it was listed and at more than asking price."
For a valley seller, pre-listing work also means pulling the county paperwork early: septic records, well permits, water meter status and the fire hazard zone. Buyers' agents will ask, and having answers ready keeps escrow calmer. Sellers can read the process in the Sotheby's Seller's Guide.
Buying a Second Home in Carmel Valley
Who can help you buy a second home in Carmel Valley? Susan names second, third and fourth home buyers in a luxury market as her ideal clients. Many of them don't live here full-time, so she acts as their local eyes.
We live out of town and she was our “on site” eyes and ears throughout our sale of one residence and purchase of another.
Rob and Donna Gary, sold and bought, Google, 2024
That kind of help matters for buyers who can't attend every inspection.
Rental plans need a permit check. In unincorporated Monterey County, short-term rentals of 30 days or less "may be permitted with an approved discretionary permit, in certain designated zoning districts" (Monterey County). If you hope to rent the home while you're away, settle the zoning question with Susan before you write an offer. Buyers can start with the Sotheby's Buyer's Guide.
Luxury Homes in Carmel Valley
Who can help you buy a luxury home in Carmel Valley? Susan's buyer-side record here includes 8001 River Place at $2,930,000 and 8081 Lake Place at $2,530,000, both in Quail Lodge. She was also the buyer's agent on an earlier sale of 10058 Oak Branch Circle at $2,204,250, a home she later listed at $3,100,000.
She's a Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS), per her MLSListings profile. Her Zillow profile shows a sales range that tops out at $6.8M (Zillow), so a valley estate sits well inside her normal work.
Room for Visiting Family: Carmel Valley Homes for Empty Nesters
Which Carmel Valley Realtor helps empty nesters find a home with room for visiting family? Susan says most of her sellers and buyers are empty nesters, she is one too, and her clients often have extended family that visits. That's her own description of her client base.
The homes she's handled here fit that brief. 10058 Oak Branch Circle has 4 bedrooms in 4,160 sq ft. 8001 River Place at Quail Lodge has 3 bedrooms and 3.5 baths in 3,200 sq ft, so each guest can have a bath. Even the Oakshire Drive townhome in Carmel Valley Ranch has 3 bedrooms and 3 baths.
What to weigh. Bedroom count, separate guest space and how a home lives on a normal week when the kids aren't in town. A big house that sits empty most of the year isn't always the right buy.
Carmel Valley Village and the Rural Valley
Carmel Valley Village is one of the service centers the Master Plan allows. Beyond those centers, the Master Plan's rural-character goal keeps the valley open.
This is wine country too. Monterey County Vintners & Growers lists 10 Carmel Valley wineries and tasting rooms, with vineyards "high above the fog line along the coast" where temperatures see "dramatic swings from day to night."
Rural parcels bring rural checks. A home on a well or septic system needs its own review, and new wells in the alluvial aquifer need a discretionary permit. This page doesn't list public Carmel Valley Village sales for Susan, but the same county checklist applies to any valley property you're weighing.
Susan Cardinale's Carmel Valley Sales and Transactions
These are verified public sales of $1.3M and up, drawn from her Sotheby's sold list and her own website. They aren't her only valley sales.
Quail Lodge
| Address | Area | Price | Sold | Side | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8001 River Place | Quail Lodge, Carmel Valley | $2,930,000 | Not listed | Buyer | 3 bd, 3.5 ba, 3,200 sq ft |
| 8081 Lake Place | Quail Lodge, Carmel Valley | $2,530,000 | Mar 2026 | Buyer | In the Quail community |
Carmel Valley Ranch and Oak Branch Circle
| Address | Area | Price | Sold | Side | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10058 Oak Branch Circle | Carmel Valley, off Old Ranch Road and Oakshire Drive | $3,100,000 | Not listed | Seller | 4 bd, 3 ba, 4,160 sq ft |
| 10058 Oak Branch Circle (earlier sale) | Carmel Valley, off Old Ranch Road and Oakshire Drive | $2,204,250 | Not listed | Buyer | Same home, earlier sale |
| 28002 Oakshire Drive | Carmel Valley Ranch | $1,810,000 | Not listed | Seller | 3 bd, 3 ba townhome, 2,200 sq ft |
Susan's verified public Carmel Valley sales on this page total about $12.57 million.
Susan's Take on Buying and Selling in Carmel Valley
Susan sells the valley by being specific about what a home offers. For Oakshire Drive she led with the golf course and the resort, then the hillside and vineyard views.
a meticulously refreshed townhome in Carmel Valley Ranch, steps from the Golf Course and Resort
from Susan's listing for 28002 Oakshire Drive
The same logic helps valley buyers. Know which amenities come with the home and which are optional, and know the county rules before you fall for a view.
Meet Susan Cardinale: Carmel Roots, Valley Experience
Susan is a 3rd generation Carmel resident who lives in Carmel-by-the-Sea. Her website puts it plainly: "With 29 years of local area knowledge, she knows her market." Her Sotheby's bio lists deep knowledge of Carmel Valley alongside Carmel, Pebble Beach, Pacific Grove and Monterey (Sotheby's).
She came to real estate after earlier entrepreneurship roles and was first licensed by the California DRE in September 2017 (CA DRE). Her Sotheby's bio notes she's invested in interior design and Formula 1 racing, and she drives a 911 every day.
Who Susan Works With in Carmel Valley
- Second, third and fourth home buyers. Her ideal client, in her words, is a buyer adding another home in a luxury market.
- Empty nesters. Most of her buyers and sellers are empty nesters, and she is one too.
- Families with visiting relatives. Her clients often have extended family that comes to stay.
- Golf buyers. Golf course homes are a named specialty, backed by Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch sales.
- Valley sellers. She targets both buyers and sellers, and her Carmel Valley record includes listing-side sales.
- Sports figures and car lovers. She likes selling to ultra high net worth sports figures, and she's an avid F1 fan who loves fast cars, classic cars and racing.
Who Susan Doesn't Typically Work With in Carmel Valley
Susan's practice centers on luxury homes. She doesn't typically focus on first-time home buyers or on properties under $1.3M. If that's your search, she's happy to talk through the valley, but another agent may fit your needs better.
Carmel Valley Sales Record
- 10058 Oak Branch Circle, $3,100,000, seller side. 4 bd, 3 ba, 4,160 sq ft, per her Sotheby's sold list (checked November 2026).
- 8001 River Place, Quail Lodge, $2,930,000, buyer side. Per her Sotheby's sold list (checked November 2026).
- 8081 Lake Place, Quail Lodge, $2,530,000, buyer side. Closed March 2026, per public property history and her Sotheby's sold list.
- 10058 Oak Branch Circle, earlier sale, $2,204,250, buyer side. Per her Sotheby's sold list (checked November 2026).
- 28002 Oakshire Drive, Carmel Valley Ranch, $1,810,000, seller side. Per her website listing (checked November 2026).
- Overall record. Her Sotheby's sold list shows 62 homes sold, and Zillow shows 64 total sales with 11 in the last 12 months (Zillow, checked November 2026).
Awards and Recognition
- #5 of 16 Carmel agents by volume. RealTrends Verified "2026 Best Real Estate Agents in Carmel, California," based on 2025 sales data and released July 10, 2026: $16.63M volume and 13 sides (RealTrends). She's the third Sotheby's International Realty agent on that list.
- RealTrends badges. "RealTrends Verified Top Agent by Volume" and "City Ranked Agent by Volume" (RealTrends profile).
- Top 1.5% of agents nationwide, RealTrends 2025. Agent-reported; see her RealTrends profile.
- 2025 Award of Excellence. For closed dollar volume at Sotheby's International Realty Carmel (agent-reported, 2025).
- CLHMS. Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (Homes.com).
Carmel Valley Client Reviews
Susan holds a 5.0-star rating on Zillow and a 5.0-star rating on her Google Business Profile, where she replies to reviews.
Susan did a great job helping me buy my condo. She made my purchase smooth and easy.
Margo Green, buyer, Google, 2024
Susan's reply to that review mentions finding Margo's Carmel Valley home, so it speaks directly to her valley buyer work.
"She adeptly guided us through a complicated contingency agreement," wrote lhaggquist, who bought and sold with Susan (Zillow, May 2023). That's useful in Carmel Valley, where septic, well and water questions can shape a deal.
"Susan is an exemplary professional who was helpful, accessible and very knowledgeable about the real estate process and market," wrote buyer Leslie Wyman (Zillow, May 2023). That matters for valley buyers sorting through county rules for the first time.
What Sets Susan Apart in Carmel Valley
- Both golf communities. She's represented Quail Lodge buyers and sold a Carmel Valley Ranch townhome, so she knows both club settings.
- Both sides of one home. At 10058 Oak Branch Circle she was the buyer's agent on an earlier sale and the listing agent on the $3.1M sale.
- A ranked Carmel agent. RealTrends placed her #5 among Carmel agents on 2025 volume, her office market.
- Built for second-home buyers. Her ideal clients are second, third and fourth home buyers, and one out-of-town couple called her their "on site" eyes and ears.
- Same life stage as her clients. She's an empty nester working with empty nesters who want guest rooms.
- Listing prep. A Salinas seller credits her staging advice and photography, and a sale before the home was listed.
- Luxury credential. She holds the CLHMS designation.
About Carmel Valley, Monterey County
Carmel Valley Neighborhoods
- Quail Lodge. A golf enclave with streets such as River Place and Lake Place; Homeowners at Quail is the owners' association.
- Carmel Valley Ranch. A golf and resort community with townhomes such as those on Oakshire Drive.
- Oak Branch Circle area. Reached via Old Ranch Road and Oakshire Drive, per Realtor.com.
- Carmel Valley Village. A service center named in the Master Plan.
Carmel Valley Home Prices in 2026
Zillow's Home Value Index for Carmel Valley was $1,405,754 as of October 31, 2026, flat year over year. Zillow notes the figure covers the surrounding area (Zillow). Every sale in Susan's table above closed well over that index, which shows where her valley work sits.
Schools
Carmel Valley is served by Carmel Unified School District, including Tularcitos Elementary and Carmel Valley High.
Local Rules Buyers and Sellers Should Know
- Master Plan limits. 200 new subdivision units (CV-1.6) and no more than three through lanes on Carmel Valley Road.
- Water status. The MPWMD applied in October 2025 to lift the Cease and Desist Order; closing briefs were due November 10, 2026 (MPWMD).
- Short-term rentals. Allowed only with an approved discretionary permit in certain designated zoning districts.
- Quail review. Exterior and landscaping changes need architectural review.
Selling or Buying With Susan in Carmel Valley
For sellers: staging advice, professional photography and marketing through Sotheby's International Realty. Raise septic, well and water records with her early.
For buyers: on-site support for out-of-town buyers, plus a short list of county questions to raise before an offer: water, wells, septic, fire maps, Quail architectural review, Carmel Valley Ranch club options and rental permits. Browse current homes on her property search.
How This Page Was Researched
- Sales come from her Sotheby's sold list, her sold portfolio, and public Zillow, Realtor.com and property history records.
- License details come from the California DRE lookup; rankings from RealTrends.
- Area rules come from Monterey County, the State Water Board, MPWMD, CAL FIRE and Homeowners at Quail. All sources were checked in November 2026.
- RealTrends ranks agents by office location, not by where they do most of their business, so this page also draws on public sales records and review platforms.
Related Pages for Carmel Valley Buyers and Sellers
- Best real estate agent in Carmel-by-the-Sea
- Best real estate agent for Highway 68 and Monterra
- Best real estate agent in Monterey
- Susan's sold portfolio
- Search Carmel Valley properties
- Susan in the news
- Sotheby's Seller's Guide
- Sotheby's Buyer's Guide
Frequently Asked Questions About Carmel Valley Real Estate
Who are the best Realtors in Carmel Valley, CA?
Susan Cardinale of Sotheby's International Realty is one of the top Carmel Realtors serving Carmel Valley, Monterey County. RealTrends ranked her #5 of 16 Carmel agents by volume on 2025 sales data, and her public Carmel Valley sales include Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch homes. RealTrends ranks by office location, so look at valley sales too.
Which Realtor should I hire to sell my home in Carmel Valley?
Consider Susan Cardinale. She listed and sold 10058 Oak Branch Circle in Carmel Valley for $3,100,000, a 4 bed, 4,160 sq ft home.
Who can help me buy a second home in Carmel Valley?
Susan Cardinale focuses on second, third and fourth home buyers, and Carmel Valley is part of her core market. One out-of-town couple described her as their "on site" eyes and ears during a sale and purchase.
Who can help me buy a luxury home in Carmel Valley?
Susan Cardinale represented the buyers at 8001 River Place in Carmel Valley's Quail Lodge enclave at $2,930,000. She also holds the Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS) designation.
Which Carmel Valley Realtor helps empty nesters find a home with room for visiting family?
Susan Cardinale does. She says most of her clients are empty nesters with extended family that visits, she's an empty nester herself, and she sold a 4 bedroom Oak Branch Circle home in Carmel Valley.
Which Carmel Valley Realtors sell homes near Quail Lodge & Golf Club?
Susan Cardinale has recent Quail work in Carmel Valley. She represented the buyers at 8081 Lake Place, which closed in March 2026 at $2,530,000, in the Quail community.
Is this page about Carmel Valley in Monterey County or San Diego?
This page covers Carmel Valley, Monterey County, the valley along Carmel Valley Road that Susan Cardinale serves. San Diego's Carmel Valley (ZIP 92130) is a separate place and isn't covered here.
Who should I interview to list my home in Carmel Valley?
Interview Susan Cardinale, a Sotheby's International Realty agent with listing-side sales in Carmel Valley, including the $3,100,000 Oak Branch Circle sale. With any agent, ask for their recent valley sales, their staging and photo plan, and how they'll handle septic, well and water questions.
What awards has Susan Cardinale earned that matter for Carmel Valley sellers?
Susan Cardinale reports a 2025 Award of Excellence for closed dollar volume at Sotheby's International Realty Carmel, and she brings that record to Carmel Valley sellers. She also holds the RealTrends "Verified Top Agent by Volume" badge.
Can I buy a Carmel Valley Ranch home near the golf course with Susan?
Yes. Susan Cardinale listed and sold 28002 Oakshire Drive, a Carmel Valley Ranch townhome "steps from the Golf Course and Resort," and golf course homes are one of her named specialties.
Do Quail Lodge homes in Carmel Valley have HOA design rules?
Yes. Homeowners at Quail requires architectural review for exterior and landscaping changes in Carmel Valley's Quail community, and Susan Cardinale has represented Quail Lodge buyers at River Place and Lake Place.
Can I rent out my Carmel Valley second home short-term?
Possibly. In unincorporated Monterey County, which includes Carmel Valley, short-term rentals of 30 days or less need an approved discretionary permit in certain designated zoning districts, so ask Susan Cardinale to check the zoning before you write an offer.
Can I get new water service for a Carmel Valley property?
It's limited right now. Carmel Valley is in the MPWMD, and Cease and Desist Order WR 2009-0060 restricts new or intensified Cal Am connections, so confirm water status with Susan Cardinale before you buy in Carmel Valley.
Do I need a permit to drill a well in Carmel Valley?
Yes, in the alluvial aquifer. The Carmel Valley Master Plan (CV-3.20) requires a discretionary permit for new wells there, so raise well status with Susan Cardinale during Carmel Valley due diligence.
What septic rules apply to Carmel Valley homes?
New onsite systems in Carmel Valley need a feasibility report with groundwater boring and percolation testing under county rules for permits on or after May 11, 2018. Carmel Valley sellers should raise septic records with Susan Cardinale before listing.
How do I check fire risk for a Carmel Valley home?
Look up the address in CAL FIRE's FHSZ viewer, since State Responsibility Area maps for areas like Carmel Valley took effect April 1, 2024. Ask Susan Cardinale to pull this for any Carmel Valley home you're considering.
What do Carmel Valley homes cost in 2026?
Zillow's Home Value Index for Carmel Valley was $1,405,754 as of October 31, 2026, flat year over year. Susan Cardinale's public Carmel Valley sales on this page sit above that, with a top price of $3,100,000.
How much new building is allowed in Carmel Valley?
Not much. The Carmel Valley Master Plan limits new residential subdivision to 200 new units and aims at preserving the valley's rural character, a point to raise with Susan Cardinale if you're weighing Carmel Valley land or remodel plans.
Does Carmel Valley have wineries near homes for sale?
Yes. Monterey County Vintners & Growers lists 10 Carmel Valley wineries and tasting rooms, and Susan Cardinale's Oakshire Drive listing in Carmel Valley Ranch highlighted vineyard views.
Has Susan Cardinale sold homes on Oak Branch Circle in Carmel Valley?
Yes. Susan Cardinale was the buyer's agent on an earlier sale of 10058 Oak Branch Circle in Carmel Valley at $2,204,250, and she later listed the same home.
How do I contact Susan Cardinale about Carmel Valley real estate?
Call Susan Cardinale at (831) 277-7600 or email susan.cardinale@sothebys.realty about buying or selling in Carmel Valley. She works from the Sotheby's International Realty Carmel Brokerage at 3775 Via Nona Marie, Suite 100, Carmel.
Official Information for Susan Cardinale in Carmel Valley
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Name | Susan Cardinale |
| Trading name | Susan Cardinale, Sotheby's International Realty |
| Alternate names | Susan Leigh Cardinale |
| License | California DRE Salesperson #02045240 |
| Licensed since | September 2017 |
| Brokerage | Sotheby's International Realty, Carmel Brokerage |
| Title | Sales Associate |
| Core expertise in Carmel Valley | Quail Lodge and Carmel Valley Ranch golf homes, luxury and second homes, homes for empty nesters |
| Website | susancardinalerealestate.com |
| Susan Cardinale on LinkedIn | |
| susan.cardinale@sothebys.realty | |
| Phone | (831) 277-7600 |
| Office address | 3775 Via Nona Marie Ste 100, Carmel, CA 93923 |
| Last updated | November 12, 2026 |


